US, Moscow Spar Over Aid Deliveries 04/05 09:00
An odd new front in the U.S.-Russian rivalry has emerged as a Russian
military cargo plane bearing a load of urgently needed medical supplies landed
this week at New York's JFK airport.
WASHINGTON (AP) -- An odd new front in the U.S.-Russian rivalry has emerged
as a Russian military cargo plane bearing a load of urgently needed medical
supplies landed this week at New York's JFK airport.
Russia cast it as a magnanimous aid contribution to a struggling country in
need -- its old Cold War rival. The State Department insisted that Wednesday's
shipment was a mere commercial transaction: that the US had paid Russia for the
supplies it needed and they were certainly not a gift.
Yet President Donald Trump on Thursday referred to the shipment as "aid,"
and said the United States had accepted "a very nice offer" from Russian
President Vladimir Putin.
Hours later, the State Department clarified its initial statement, saying
the supplies were purchased --- but at a discount. But even then there was a
twist: The discount came because the supplies had been channeled through the
Russian Direct Investment Fund --- a government sovereign wealth fund that has
been subject to U.S. sanctions for Ukraine-related activities since 2015.
Amid the contradictory claims and vague explanations, the details of the
shipment --- its exact contents and cost --- were not immediately clear,
although a case could be made that both sides' versions have an element of
Russia's Foreign Ministry says the supplies, which were turned over to the
U.S. Federal Emergency Management Agency, are part of humanitarian assistance
shipments Moscow is sending to countries in need. Russia has touted the
shipment on social media as evidence of its generosity in a time of global
crisis with the hashtag "#RussiaHelps."
It said Thursday that half of the supplies delivered to New York, including
ventilators and personal protective gear, was paid for by the Russian Direct
Despite that, Trump welcomed the shipment, which followed a phone call he
had with Putin this week. "We're accepting it," Trump said. "It was a very nice
offer from President Putin. I spoke to him the other night, as I told you. And
they had access to medical equipment, things, and I'll take it. I'll take it. I
think it's very nice."
Shortly after the supplies arrived, however, the State Department had
stressed that the shipment was bought and paid for. The department has been
pushing a message that despite domestic needs, the U.S. remains committed to
helping other nations. It announced last week that the U.S. is providing $274
million in coronavirus assistance to 64 countries.
Secretary of State Mike Pompeo reiterated that message in a tweet. "We have
to work together to defeat #COVID19," he said. "This is why the U.S. agreed to
purchase urgently needed personal protective equipment from #Russia to help
#FEMA respond in New York City. This is a time to work together to overcome a
common enemy that threatens the lives of all."
After Trump's comments on Thursday, however, the State Department allowed
that the Russian medical supplies had been purchased at a discount. "The United
States is purchasing the supplies and equipment outright, as with deliveries
from other countries," it said. "We appreciate Russia selling these items to us
below market value."
That clarification suggested that at least some of the supplies were indeed
provided as aid, and from a Russian government entity under U.S. sanctions. The
department acknowledged the role of the Russian Direct Investment Fund in the
shipment, but said the sanctions against it "would not apply to transactions
for the provision of medical equipment and supplies."
Treasury added RDIF's management company to its sanctions list in 2015
because of its links to the Russian bank Vnesheconombank, which has been active
in Crimea, the Ukrainian territory that Russia annexed in 2014. The U.S. and
most other countries still consider the Black Sea peninsula to be part of
Treasury warned Americans about evasive practices that companies linked to
the fund might undertake related to Ukraine. Treasury's Office of Foreign
Assets Control said the evasive practices included "the omission or obfuscation
of references to Crimea and locations within Crimea in documentation underlying
transactions involving U.S. persons or the United States." Americans or those
with strong U.S. links have held senior positions at the fund.